This list was last updated on May 28, 2019:
| Player | Offense(s) | Punishment |
| Moosebobby | Harassing players with hateful and anti-Semitic comments | Permanent Ban |
| Aron | Sending unsolicited and inappropriate photos/messages to players | Permanent Ban |
| ChessLlama | Leaking dev info and documents, attempting to sabotage server development | Permanent Ban |
| Whisperer195 | Attempting to sabotage server development | Permanent Ban |
| Axio | Attempting to sabotage server development | Permanent Ban |
| ElementalChicken | Supporting sabotage of server development | Permanent Ban |
| N**G***** | Spamming inappropriate words/server raiding | Permanent Ban |
| rmac | Spamming inappropriate words/server raiding | Permanent Ban |
| Zyphaex / Sir_Innocent / Samo_Smithy / Atlas_Admin / FrankieOnThePC | Using racist slurs in Global chat, then trying to bypass punishment with 3 alts | Permanent Ban |
| Player | Offense(s) | Punishment |
| idako_the_wizard | Being a dick to several players consistently throughout the dev period | 6k Purgatory sentence |
| v4x | Abusing his dev server access to get a good starting spot on the server | 6k Purgatory sentence |
| Sprix | Using a racist slur in Global chat | 6k Purgatory sentence |
| XBilbo_SwaggingsX | Getting muted, then insulting staff through /link | 6k Purgatory sentence |
| Cqrson | Door Glitching to raid a town | 6k Purgatory sentence |
| SaltPigeon | Abusing XP bugs | 6k Purgatory sentence |
| Allidoisdig1234 | Mocking players in the forums | 6k Purgatory sentence |
| Raxius | Mocking players in the forums | 6k Purgatory sentence |
| Archibishob_Avery | Mocking players who were punished | 6k Purgatory sentence |
| BrodieGeek | Using an alt and using racist slurs | 6k Purgatory sentence |
| v4x | Exploitation of bugs and disrespecting staff numerous times | 50k Purgatory sentence |
| Anmar | Shit talking players online. | 6k Purgatory sentence |
| Uthrid_Ragnyrsen | Incendiary remarks and disrespecting staff | 6k Purgatory sentence |
| HeyItsDevil | Block Glitching through a door to raid a building | 6k Purgatory sentence |
| I_suck_at_PC | Block Glitching through a door to raid a building | 6k Purgatory sentence |
| Zhevvy | Not reporting planned harm against server | 10k Purgatory sentence |
| Icarus_TM | Movement and speed hacks | 10k Purgatory sentence |
| WarpWing | Not reporting planned harm against server | 10k Purgatory sentence |
| Guldlaksen | Exploiting a potions bug without reporting it | 4k Purgatory sentence |
| Vanate | Exploiting a potions bug without reporting it | 4k Purgatory sentence |
| Hatron | Exploiting a potions bug without reporting it | 4k Purgatory sentence |
| BadSniper | Exploiting a potions bug without reporting it | 4k Purgatory sentence |
| Boice | Using a racist slur | 2k Purgatory sentence |
| Wudji | Racist slurs and offensive language | 2k Purgatory sentence |
| Eldric_Greyson | Using a homophobic slur | 2k Purgatory sentence |
| Saltpigeon | Harassment and toxicity | 4k Purgatory sentence |
| burri | Ignoring staff when told to stop toxic behavior | 6k Purgatory sentence |
| YourAverageDude | Ignoring staff when told to stop toxic behavior | 2k Purgatory sentence |
| Djscales101 | Incessant chat spam | 6k Purgatory sentence |
| Wemb | Spam and racist slurs | 10k Purgatory sentence |
| ExplodingBull | Spam and racist slurs | 10k Purgatory sentence |
| Rikuskie | Using a minimap mod | 10k Purgatory sentence |
| Skipper_Wood | Deliberately despawning players' items by breaking chests | 4k Purgatory sentence |
